• This topic has 23 replies, 13 voices, and was last updated 4 weeks ago by Katherine.
Viewing 11 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #2980
      Sharon
      Member

      Do you believe there is a difference between managers and leaders? Explain your position and provide examples.

    • #53731
      Emma
      Participant

      I do believe you can be both, you also can be one or the other. A great manger should also be a great leader. Mangers have to focus on the enforcing the policy’s and procedures while a leader will lead and support you through them. I feel that a leader is more front line where a manger is in the background and not seen as often. Your peers are more likely to utilize a leader as they are more available.

      Example: You have a resident whose family has complex family dynamics which is impacting the residents care decisions as they often disagree. A leader is able to listen to the staff concerns about the residents quality of life, they are also able to listen to the complex family whom have different opinions on how their loved one should be treated/taken care of. The leader is able to arrange these meetings, organize and document everyone’s thoughts and opinions. Presenting everyone’s views and working through this high stress situation. finding common ground and while presenting facts and maintain professionalism. Supporting care staff and family with decisions and directions decided upon. A Leader should always take a holistic approach to each task to ensure that all aspects of the task is considered.

      • #53841
        Jennifer
        Participant

        Hi Emma,
        I like your example and feel like it comes from experience. Family dynamics can be so complicated at times that it truly takes a great leader to be able to navigate certain situations. I really like your use of the word holistic. I think that’s a great way to think about how an effective leader would interact with the world around them.

    • #53781
      Elena
      Participant

      Yes, I believe there is a difference between managers and leaders, although their roles can be similar and overlapping. Both are important for providing safe and good-quality patient care. A nurse manager is responsible for organizing the daily work of the nursing team. A nurse leader focuses more on supporting, motivating, and encouraging other nurses. A leader does not always need to have a management position. For example, a nurse leader can be an experienced nurse within a group of peers who supports coworkers, shares knowledge, and motivates the team. A nurse leader can also disagree with management about how the workload is organized. This can sometimes lead to positive changes in management and workplace organization. If a group of nurses, supported by one or more leaders, believes that certain working conditions are unsafe for staff or patients, they can speak up and encourage changes in policies and practices.

      • #53799
        Emma
        Participant

        This is a very relatable example. At my place of work we have RPNs whom supervise the floor (unregulated health care professionals (Dietary, PSW’s, Activation, housekeeping) who work on that unit that day) therefore many of our RPN’s have strong leadership skills and often have to be strong advocates for their units. The RN’s in the buildings then oversee the RPNs. I often find myself having to report to the RN’s about a new complex resident whom needs more support and having to take that leadership position to advocate and organize what is needed for that individual.

        • #53801
          Dayna
          Participant

          This is a fantastic example. I agree as I have experienced this as well working in LTC. When I was working in LTC, the nurses on the floor are the leaders for the group. We had to delegate the sections, organize the schedules for baths, chart and also give report. The PSWs, Dietary aids, etc. would come to the floor nurse with any concerns that need to be reported. In the LTC facility was also a nursing manager who would take care of anything urgent and have other duties that are off the floor. Often the floor nurse would continue to lead any situations and go to the Nursing Manager for emergencies.

        • #53832
          Karolina
          Participant

          I think RPN should be a leader in her own right. RPN should take “ownership” of her unit and her work and lead UHP. Leadership is such a broad topic and everybody can be a leader in their own profession, and role.

    • #53787
      Mark
      Participant

      Yes, I do believe that there is a difference between managers and leaders. I feel that they do overlap, however are not the same, as a manager focuses more on tasks and processes, organizing, managing performance and relies on authority where a good leader focuses on the people and purpose, inspiration for people to do their best, while earning influence and trust.

      Example: A good example in the healthcare setting would be that the manager of a certain area is managing the performance of the staff, plans, organizes the department and monitors, often relying on authority. The leader, (Charge Nurse) is working directly with people for purpose, developing other staff by encouraging improvement and change. They think about the bigger picture overall.

      • #53813
        Chad
        Participant

        I agree with this. I like the leader in this situation, these environments make the team feel like a part of the team and not just another number. This environment fosters innovation and job satisfaction, and better care for clients.

      • #53900
        Jessica
        Participant

        I really like the points you made about the difference between managers and leaders. I agree that although their roles can overlap, leadership is more about inspiring and supporting people, building trust, and helping others grow. I also like your example in the healthcare setting because it shows how a manager and a leader can work together toward the same goal while having different responsibilities. I believe that strong leadership can make a big difference in the workplace, especially in healthcare, where teamwork, communication, and supporting one another are so important

    • #53800
      Dayna
      Participant

      Yes, I do feel there are differences between leaders and managers. I do also feel that you cannot have one without the other. Looking back on my reflection and reading the leadership traits, I realize that these two come as a pair. To be a good manager, you need to have great leadership skills. To be a leader, you need to have good manager skills. They each need to compliment one another to help you succeed in your role.

      To be a leader, I feel you need to have many skills that include: being approachable; trustworthy; empathetic; energetic; a long with many other skills.

      To be a manager, you need to be: knowledgeable of the company or roll you are in; organized; and a good planner.

      Being a leader/manager, you are continuously learning new traits about yourself on how to approach different situations. Every situation and team is unique.

      Example: Being a PSS supervisor, I have been able to learn different traits about myself and develope ideas on how to become a better leader for my staff. Coming into this role, I first had to gain my staff’s trust. I have also learned that you cannot make everyone happy. Sometimes you have to have difficult conversations, some positive and you also need to learn to delegate tasks and follow up. I have learned that you can be approachable as well as being more structured.

      • #53840
        Jennifer
        Participant

        Excellent points Dayna. I wholeheartedly agree that the terms should coexist. Ideally, all managers would have the leadership skills you mentioned and understand the intricacies of each individual situation and those involved. I also agree that a leader must remain open-minded and willing to learn. We cannot anticipate every situation in an ever-changing environment, but being able to recognize our weaknesses and ask for help can be as equally valuable as understanding our strengths. Your example also resonates with me as I remember my first position as a charge nurse. It was a huge learning curve and it took some time until my colleagues got to know me and began to trust me. – Thanks for sharing! (This may be a silly question, but what is a PSS?)

        • #53978
          Katherine
          Participant

          I agree with you and your point of view of having both characteristic to being an effective leader you need to be an effective leader and a diligent manager. Great post.

    • #53812
      Chad
      Participant

      Yes I believe their is a difference between a manager and leader. However, it’s not so black and white. A manager can also be a leader and good managers are. A leader can also be a manager.

      To be effective I believe a manager needs be a leader.

      I have held many positions with managers only, and job satisfaction, support, motivation are usually lacking in the workplace. I have also been privileged to work with leaders who advocate, question processes, support staff and encourage and motivate staff to care.

      Example:
      A client complains about the care received.
      Manager will follow procedure and document and ensure all policies followed. In this case the staff involved may feel unsupported.

      A leader will listen to the concerns of client, investigate and involve the team and use it as an opportunity to educate and improve. Under this approach the staff feel not only supported but included.

      • #53815
        Elena
        Participant

        Thank you for your post. I agree that there can sometimes be a lack of leadership in management, but I believe it should not be this way. The qualities of a good leader should also be part of being a good manager. Anyone can learn to follow procedures, organize daily tasks, and manage routines, but not everyone can be empathetic, communicate well, and involve the whole team in solving problems. In my opinion, management skills can be taught and learned, but leadership is more complex. Leadership is also connected to a person’s personality, values, and beliefs, which influence the way we work and provide care in healthcare.

      • #53868
        Sarina
        Participant

        Well said Chad! You’re right, the most effective managers I’ve worked with are also incredible leaders! I’m lucky to work with a few managers now who really take time to listen to concerns and opinions and involve the interdisciplinary team in the process to help build a holistic approach for our residents and their people of importance, and it makes a huge difference!

    • #53835
      Jennifer
      Participant

      Yes, I believe there is a difference between managers and leaders. Perhaps it’s fair to say that managers who lack the traits and skills of good leaders typically care about one thing: the bottom line. They want to know the “how and when” of a situation rather than the “what and why.” They are not concerned about seeking improvement for all individuals involved or interested in challenging the system. They want things to run smoothly in order to create the most optimal output. This may be an ideal outlook for an individual running a factory line (though, even then I doubt it) but in health care people should not be seen as numbers.

      Leaders, on the other hand, want to know the what and why of everything. They want to make improvements, challenge and cultivate ideas, foster growth and relationships. They are willing to admit mistakes or that they do not know and open to others’ opinions and ideas. They demonstrate their leadership by being willing to work alongside their team, knowing when to step back and standing up for something they believe in or if something unjust has occurred.

      An example might be working with elderly clientele in a LTC facility and having a incontinence product allotment for a particular floor and suddenly that allotment is no longer enough. In this scenario, manager might scold the staff and expect to get back to the regular numbers asap. Whereas a leader would dig deeper, verifying the reason for the need and taking the time to learn the bigger picture, before coming up with a best case solution based on inclusive input moving forward.

      In a perfect world, all managers would be leaders.

      • #53873
        Nadia
        Participant

        Hi Jennifer,
        Reading your point of view on the differences between a leader and a manager has educated me on how leaders foster growth and relationships through being open to other opinions. I believe it’s important for a leader to have such a trait since it helps gain the trust of an individual.

    • #53855
      Karolina
      Participant

      Leadership skills develop over time and coming with experience as well as exposure to different roles. Having that kind of experience in different medical fields gives opportunity to develop leadership abilities. Ex. leadership in the surgical theatre is much different from the experience in LTC. You need different set of skills, however some skills are still universal.

    • #53869
      Leona
      Participant

      I do believe there is a difference between being a manager and a leader. Despite this belief, there can be a perfect balance between both. Leadership qualities are found in great managers and manager qualities are found in great leaders. In our field, I find that people with more leadership based positions work on the floor while managers work behind the scenes.

      For example, a leader within nursing notices that their team is stressed and overwhelmed. They encourage everyone, help newer nurses prioritize patient care, and motivate the team to work together to make sure patients revieve proper/safe care.
      The nurse manager notices that there are not enough people scheduled for a shift. They re=arrange staff assignmemts, contact avaialble nurses, and organize the work load to ensure every patient recieves care.

      In conclusion, the leadership role focuses more on motivating and guiding the nursing team while the management role focsuses on organization and resources to solve a problem.

    • #53871
      Nadia
      Participant

      I believe a leader and a manager’s roles overlap. In order, to be an excellent manager I believe that one needs to be a leader first. Since a leader should be patient, trustworthy, confident and know how to work under stress. while a manger may need to work on enforcing policy for the organization but at the same will need to know need to have the confidence to enforce it.

      • #53872
        Leona
        Participant

        I completely agree with your perspective. Both roles require similar skills/qualities, often overlapping eachother.

    • #53899
      Jessica
      Participant

      I believe there is a difference between managers and leaders. A manager is often responsible for organizing work, making sure tasks are completed, and ensuring that policies and procedures are followed. A leader, on the other hand, inspires, motivates, and supports others to work toward a common goal. I do not believe that someone needs to be a manager to be a leader. Leadership can happen at any level of an organization, regardless of a person’s job title. For example, a person can demonstrate leadership by supporting their coworkers, sharing ideas, helping solve problems, and setting a positive example. In a community health centre, I believe leadership is important because we all have a role in supporting one another and providing the best possible care and services to our community.

    • #53974
      Katherine
      Participant

      There are a few differences between being a leader and a manager. First of all Managers usually manage people and the daily functions on a unit. In healthcare that means they manage people, and manage expectations of the organization. Managers also are responsible for scheduling and evaluating people and the firing, firing and disciplinary actions for individuals.

      Leaders do not need formal titles to be passion and questions the status quo that most leaders do. Most importantly leaders do not necessarily want to manage people. Leaders focus on the vision, inspiring long term culture of the organization. Leaders are also passionate about patient care and are focus on inspiring their team mates to be the best they can be.

Viewing 11 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this Discussion Thread.